Today's Headlines
- Two Exhibitions Are On At Ramoma, Nairobi
- Country to Review Tourism Law
- Econet Wireless Finally Rolls Out
- Odinga Warns of Civil Unrest
- Mulee Rules Out Harambee Stars U-Turn
- Taking Up a Women's Agenda
- More Than 6,000 Christian Youth Converge for Prayers
- Catholic Church Outraged By MPs' Refusal to Pay Tax
- Pope Benedict Praying for Release of Abducted Nuns
- Thousands Flee Amid Fears of Border Clashes
- Malaria Rates Plummet Among Children
- Winning Against HIV Stigma Behind Bars
- First Congress of Federation of African Journalists a Historic Milestone, Says IFJ
- Archbishop Lele Urges State to Act as Food Crisis Bites
- Regional Workshop Focus Border Management, Irregular Migration
- Silverbird Acquires Kenya's Nu Metro, Starts Operations in Ghana
- Raila is Evil, Says Minister
- Man Charged With Abduction of Two Catholic Sisters
- UN Censures State On Torture
- Agencies Seek $390 Million to Offset Climate And Food Risks
- UN-Backed Scheme Gives 3,000 Prisoners Clean Water and Sanitation
- Samosa Festival is On in Nairobi
- Heartstrings in Another Comedy
- Govts, Investors Engage RVR in Rail Bid
- Mwangi Replaces Mwebesa At NSE
- Riepa Hosts Business Association
- ICTR Petitions UN for Arrest of Kabuga
- UBA to Invest SH360 Billion in Kenya
- Free Movement of People Too, Not Just Goods and Capital
- Judges Running Out of Money?
The Nation (Nairobi)
October 1, 2008
Opinion Article By Jaindi Kisero
I don't understand why the chairman of the Nairobi Stock Exchange, Mr James Wangunyu, has decided to send mixed signals on the planned Cooperative Bank of Kenya Initial Public Offering.
One day he says the prevailing bearish conditions in the market are not conducive for an IPO and that the flotation should be postponed.
A few days later, he changes tune and signs a statement saying that the IPO must go on.
He does not explain the reasons for the about-turn.
In the process, and perhaps unwittingly, he creates a perfect environment for conspiracy theories.
The air is rife with rumours and all manner of claims. According to some pundits, it is all part of the perennial battle for control of IPOs by the tiny stockbroking elite that dominates the shares business in Kenya.
Is this really the time for the chairman of the NSE to start sending confusing signals about the timing of the IPO?
The NSE is yet to fully recover from the crisis of confidence it has been suffering since last year, partly due to the collapse of two large stockbrokerage firms -- but mainly as a result of the frustration, which investors went through as a consequence of delays in refunding cheques from the Safaricom IPO.
It seems that Mr Wangunyu has found himself in a position where his interests as chair of the NSE are in conflict with his position as one of the transaction advisers for the Cooperative Bank issue.
His company, Standard Investment Bank, was chosen as the lead sponsoring brokers of the Cooperative Bank issue.
My own view about the timing of the Co-op bank IPO is this: If the bank and its advisers are confident that they can structure the issue in a manner that it will still be attractive to investors -- despite the prevailing bearish conditions -- let us give them a chance to put their show on the road. In any event, this is not an offer for sale.
Unlike the Safaricom issue, it is not a privatisation where the main shareholder has chosen to get out. Cooperative Bank seeks to raise money to invest in growth and expansion. We should not put hurdles on their way.
Under the Banking Act, there are limits to the amount of money a bank can collect from the public in terms of deposits.
Indeed capital-to-deposits ratios restrict the level of deposits, which a bank can collect from the public to its capital base.
The Co-operative Bank of Kenya is at a point in its growth trajectory where it cannot engage in any meaningful expansion and growth without a massive capital injection.
Granted, the prevailing environment in the capital markets is not too good.
But remember the bearish conditions have not stopped companies from raising money for expansion and acquisitions through private placement.
To force a company to postpone its business plan until the time the Nairobi Stock Exchange starts experiencing a bull run is to be short-sighted.
Welcome to the world of casino capitalism.
Wall Street, the ultimate free market, has come tumbling down.
I like the phrase "toxic loans". Until now, we in the Developing World believed that things like derivatives were a sign of advanced capitalism. We saw them as sophisticated financial instruments.
Capitalism is supposed to work in a very straightforward way. You put your savings in a bank, which is then lent to an industrialists, who then invest it in value-adding activity -- in expansion and in building a new factory.
The financial markets in the Developed World have changed the logic.
Instead of funding activity, the preoccupation here is to use the sophisticated financial instruments to shift risk from one party to another.
Essentially, this is what the derivatives market is all about.
When they "repackage" or "securities" sub-prime mortgages, the intention is to allow the lender to sell on the risk to another party by passing on the pieces of paper mainly to investment banks.
As you pass these "toxic" pieces of paper to third parties, you justify it on the grounds that you are engaged in risk diversification. But the truth of the matter is that risk is simply transferred. It does not disappear.
When problems erupted, banks realised they had accumulated huge volumes of these toxic pieces of paper in their books.
Worse still, they did not know how much of these toxic loans were in the books of fellow banks. They stopped lending to another -- hence the crunch.
What are the policy implications for us?
Better regulation of investment banks. Maybe we should start by limiting the use of the term "bank" to institutions regulated by the Central Bank of Kenya.
We have allowed too many of the so called "investment banks" to mushroom.


